Filed Under: Anything Peaceful
Tags: Congress • maxine waters
They Don't Read the Bills
Rep. Maxine Waters of California admits that members of Congress don’t read the bills they vote on. (Of course, we already knew this.) She made the confession during an interview Friday with Norah O’Donnell on MSNBC. The subject of the interview was the provision in “stimulus” bill that prohibited interference with contractual bonuses at bailed-out companies. O’Donnell pressed Waters to say if she realized that prohibition was in the bill she voted for, and Waters admitted she did not. O’Donnell vented frustration that members of Congress are ignorant about contents of legislation. Waters explained that she and other members read the “important” parts and are mainly concerned with the amount being spent and the beneficiaries. She said they rely on staff to feed them information. When O’Donnell questioned that procedure, Waters misdirected the interview by asking O’Donnell if she reads every word of the newspaper. (As though that were relevant.) Then she asked O’Donnell if she read every word of her mortgage. Unfortunately, O’Donnell let the interview wind down instead of going in for the kill. She could have pointed out that when a person fails to read her own mortgage, she may harm herself, but congressmen vote on things that affect everyone, using money extracted forcibly by taxation, and that no one is permitted to opt out. Congressmen are largely unaccountable because any single voter’s “clout” is negligible.As Mario Rizzo has wondered, if our alleged representatives don’t know what is in the laws they pass, in what sense can we be said to have consented to be governed by them?Watch the interview for yourself:









Comment by Perry Willis on 23 March 2009:
Anyone who wants to do something about this should check out Downsize DC’s “Read the Bills Act” — http://www.downsizedc.org/etp/campaigns/27
Comment by Doug Thorson on 23 March 2009:
Sheldon,What can be more revealing than Maxine Walters ignorant approach to her position as a U. S. Representative. She was not even embarrassed by the fact that not reading the bills is SOP in congress. What is going on in congress is a display of a broken legislative process that demands fixing. I agree with Mario Rizzo’s question, “…if our alleged representatives don’t know what is in the laws they pass, in what sense can we be said to have consented to be governed by them?”The other questions I have are, who, if not our representatives, is writing the legislation that is being voted on? That question is somewhat “tongue in cheek,” since we all know it is the lawyers/staffers, but who elected them and how much power are they exerting over the process and the electorate? Did the Constitution foresee and therefore empower legislative aids to write legislation that representatives would then not read but vote “yea” or “nay” on?I’m having a train wreck and will stop now.
Comment by RickC on 23 March 2009:
Doug,If some of the stuff I’ve read it’s even worse than that. Sorry I can’t point to the exact place I read this, but as I understand it, often it is lobbyists who write regulations and legislation. Can someone tell me I’m wrong? Please?