Anything Peaceful: The Official Blog of The Freeman
Sheldon Richman

Political Sophistry

Here’s a sleazy piece of demagoguery:

  • Republicans were big spenders when they were in control of the government.
  • Republicans, hypocritically, criticize Democrats for being big spenders.
  • Ergo, arguments against big government spending are invalid.

A non sequitur, to be sure. But a highly convenient one.

There Are No Responses Yet. »

  1. It is also an extremely common fallacy to find when just talking with average people about the bailout package. I’m loath to repeat anything that GOP members inside the Beltway are saying, but in the final analysis, government spending is wrong, irrespective of which party is doing it.

  2. Obama said “The question we ask today is not whether our government is too big or too small, but whether it works…We’re guided by what works, not by any ideology ” If he is sincere, then he should take a look at the cold facts and compare how well tax cuts, deregulation, cutting government spending worked during the Reagan era and the impact that these measures had on healing a dysfunctional economy — and compare that to the spendy frenzy of FDR and the “lost decade” that followed in the 1930s. Peter Ferrara very eloquently points out in today’s opinion page of the WSJ that “a natural economic recovery will begin sometime this year, not because of the president’s policies, but because soon this will be the longest recession since World War II. However, thanks to the administration’s retrograde policies — cut from the cloth of the 1970s and even the 1930s — the recovery will not be what it should be. Rather, unemployment will remain too high, and inflation will resurge, recreating the disastrous economic results we suffered the last time Keynesian policies were dominant.”Amen.

Post a Response

  • © Copyright 2011 Freeman - Ideas on Liberty. All rights reserved.

    72 queries. 1.207 seconds